“If everything’s being played on the surface, it’s very hard to make that character come to life.
You want hinterland, you want subtext. You want the things that are buried, the things that we don’t know about them, the things that maybe they don’t know about themselves. And always, the story is about this excavation of what’s underneath the surface. One way or the other, that’s kind of what story is. It’s about bringing things to the surface,” says Conclave screenwriter Peter Straughan, about the importance of giving your characters secrets. 

In this episode, we speak to Peter Straughan about his powerful film Conclave, starring Ralph Fiennes, Stanley Tucci and John Lithgow. Based on the book by Robert Harris, the movie follows five very different modern Catholic Cardinals as they go through the process of electing a new Pope. Straughan talks about why he loves a flawed hero, getting to tour the Vatican, what surprised him the most, and whether or not he thinks the real Pope will watch this movie. 

Having also written the TV show Wolf Hall about Tudor England, Straughan also talks about the surprising connection between King Henry VIII and the modern Catholic Church. 

“Both the world of the Tudors and the world of Conclave give us a way of looking at human behavior and the pursuit of power from a sort of angle that makes it particularly clear and fresh, without the clutter of the normal secular world of elections, that really anchors it in the human individual. So, Tudor England was maybe the last time where the sexual desires of one man was going to dominate the political landscape of an entire country. Maybe not the last time. Maybe this still happens in the world. But it becomes really pared down to basics, so you see very clearly what’s going on. And I think it feels the same with Conclave, it’s about the personalities and the morals of these few individuals,” says Straughan. 

Just a warning, there are spoilers about the ending of Conclave in this episode, but we give you plenty of warning before they are discussed. 

To hear more about Straughan’s writing process, listen to the podcast.